English on the Chopping Block
by Ted Rueter
Several months ago, Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott asserted that
homosexuality is a disease, like kleptomania. Defending the religious basis
of Lott's position, House Majority Leader Dick Armey commented, "Both myself
and Senator Lott believe very strongly in the Bible."
Allen Quist, a Republican candidate for Governor of Minnesota in 1998,
stood before a group of realtors and said, "Thank you for inviting myself
What's going on here? Does anyone know how to speak proper English
anymore? Does anyone care about the decline of the language?
This "myself" affectation even rears its ugly head on National Public
Radio--that bastion of literacy. Ira Glass, host of "This American Life,"
ends each show by stating, "This program was produced by Nancy Updike and
I complained to Mr. Glass. He responded that while he knows the rules of
grammar "and how they apply to this particular case," the grammatically
correct way "doesn't sound like the way people normally talk."
The "everybody does it" defense--on NPR!
Just as "myself" often shows up incorrectly, so does "I."
have said to me, "Just between you and I..." An ad for a Minneapolis
station implores, "Join Guy Green and I every Sunday night for 'Fantasy
Another grating English misusage is "impacted" as a verb. A publication
by the Minnesota Housing Partnership states, "The impact of the housing
crisis will impact the Twin Cities for generations to come." A recruiting
by Medtronic (a pacemarker manufacturer) exhorts, "Impact a life every
minutes!" A temporary help agency advises, "Impact your career!"
colleague once said to me, "This ad isn't very impactful." Even Wolf
Blitzer has gotten into the act, asking "How will the election impact the
David Fryzell, a columnist for Writer's Digest, notes that "impact"
verb smacks of jargon, "the kind of word a university administrator would
use to avoid actually saying anything. It lends itself too easily to
obfuscation: 'The policy will negatively impact the poor' seems a
mealymouthed way around saying, 'The policy will hurt the poor.'"
And what does this horrible bastardization MEAN? Helped? Hurt?
Rescued? Damaged? And what's wrong with good old "affected," anyway?
The transformation of perfectly good nouns into awful verbs is pervasive.
The "Bulletin Board" feature of the ST. PAUL PIONEER PRESS compiles
reports on "the verbing of America." Recent contributions include
"columnize," "voucherize," "incentivize," "concretize,"
and "Cecil B.
Incorrect usages of apostrophes litter the landscape. Every day, I drive
by a billboard for "University Auto Sale's." Many people named Johnson
Smith put "Johnson's" or "Smith's" on their mailbox. A sign
at a Goodwill
says "Donation's accepted." Similarly, many businesses NEGLECT to
apostrophes, such as "Fishers Donuts" and "Todays Employment."
college students don't know the difference between "its" and "it's."
even use "its'."
But can we blame them? After all, American students live in a culture
where ABC TV News omits the comma between cities and states, and where
"Jeopardy!" (supposedly for eggheads) doesn't know that commas go
quotation marks. Students also live in a culture in which a SuperAmerica
station issued the following notice: "We are currently going through several
in store price increases, some are increases while others are decreases, you
may find that the price on the shelf does not match the price at the
In his classic essay, "Politics and the English Language," George
warned that banalities reflect a corrupted political culture.
Unfortunately, idiocies abound in common English usage. Merchants offer
"free gifts. "I could care less" somehow indicates indifference.
agree to meet at "nine am in the morning." Witnesses offer testimony
this point in time, to the best of my recollection."
Red McCombs, owner of the Minnesota Vikings, said of rookie receiver Randy
Moss (who has a troubled past), "He's been well-recepted here." (Evidently,
the people of Minnesota love professional athletes who play good,
irregardless of their background. Of course, I might have errored.)
The declne of the English language mirrors the celebration of stupidity
and mediocrity in American society. Washington mayor Marion Barry once
said, "Outside of the killings, Washington has one of the lowest crime
in the country." No episode of "Jerry Springer" is complete without
or chair toss. Each year, the Naval Academy pays tribute to the midshipman
finishing last in the class. Fifty-nine percent of public K-12 teachers in
Massachusetts recently failed 8th grade math and reading tests. Millions
paid $39.95 to watch Dennis Rodman wrestle Karl Malone. THE NATIONAL
ENQUIRER is the nation's largest-circulation newspaper.
While I'm appalled by many linguistic trends, I'm no purist. I don't
care about the distinction between "who" and "whom." I applaud
edict by the Oxford University Press that split infinitives are perfectly
acceptable. I have no idea how to diagram a sentence.
But I do know that Dick Armey should have said, "Both Senator Lott and
believe very strongly in the BIBLE."
Published in the Christian Science Monitor, December 7, 1998